Childintime wrote:Weird - I seem to remember you being super up for Nier. You not got round to it yet? Or did I remember wrong?
hylian_elf wrote:What do you think of Andy’s suggestion?10 is too many, as is the points difference between first and second with that system. No big deal though really. I can certainly come up with 5 good 'uns, maybe a couple more.
hylian_elf wrote:Let's get this thing going and thoughts floating. Usual rules (modified for 10 rather than 5 entries as so many good games this year) below, but shall we discuss making it slightly different this year? Andy suggested allowing up to 10 entries, and you give each game a score between 1 and 10, can only use a number once. So you could have Nier, Nioh and Hollow Knight and give them 5, 6 and 10 respectively depending on how well you think of the game. That way someone's second best won't just get hefty points just for being the year's second best for that person. Discuss.
Facewon wrote:Also, that's good news on superflight. On my list.
Andy wrote:Sonic Mania (I don’t know why I thought Sonic would suddenly be anything other than complete shit)
Childintime wrote:1. Nier: Automata
2. Yakuza 0
3. Persona 5
4. Emily is Away Too
5. Prey
Moot_Geeza wrote:There's plenty of stuff to add as I inevitably amend the list throughout 2018, still looking forward to playing Edith Finch, Steamwold Dig 2, Golf Story and a few others, but I'm currently thinking: 1. Mario Odyssey [10] [Thumper - Switch [10]] 2. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild [9] 3. Yakuza 0 [9] [Mario Kart Deluxe [9]] 4. Mario + Rabbids Kingdom Battle [9] 5. Sonic Mania [9] 6. Nex Machina [9] 7. Rime [8] [Shovel Knight - Specter of Torment campaign [8]] 8. ARMS [8] 9. Unacharted: Lost Legacy [7] Will add reviews when I settle on an order. ARMS has shot up in my estimation this week. I'm not putting Everybody's Golf or Horizon on there, neither were bad games but I had a few problems with them and don't just want to list everything I played. Little Nightmares didn't make it either.
Childintime wrote:Don’t worry buddy - I’ve been there. Tried for years to force myself to like Sonic but I finally realised Sonic is fundamentally shit, and will always be shit. That’s why when a Sonic game is lauded as nailing it, and “finally” being a return to “form” I know that it’s not for me - a return to form for Sonic is a return to being hard shit when it had previously been a different consistency of equally stinky shit.Andy wrote:Sonic Mania (I don’t know why I thought Sonic would suddenly be anything other than complete shit)
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!